
The white box episode might be the most anticipated and popular challenge on the HGTV reality show Design Star and last night’s version did not disappoint.
There were some beautiful rooms and a few disasters – plus lots of rushing around to get these spaces done quickly – so the episode was dramatic and fun.
Plus, Vanilla Ice was the guest judge. I’m a product of the 80s and continue to be fascinated by the transformation of this former rapper’s career, so that made his appearance a bonus.
(When I saw a preview in which Vanilla Ice actually told a designer, “If there’s a problem, you gotta solve it,” – a reference to one of his song lyrics – I actually laughed out loud!)
First, I’ll remind you that I’m personally judging this season at least in part on whether I find ideas that are inspirational. After all, what’s the point of giving a designer his own show if he can’t motivate me to try something new!
In this way, Design Star succeeded for a second straight week. My favorite ideas from last night:
- Amazing, graphic painting – on walls, cabinets and even rugs. These were all things (except maybe some phenomenal hand painting) that most of us could accomplish with a little trial and error.
- Mixed patterns. I love how a great designer can mix different patterns and still make a room feel cohesive. We saw that last night in Rachel’s room.
- Fun light fixtures. My favorite was the chandelier created by Britany (at right) that incorporated a lattice panel, varying lengths of gold chain and an inverted table lamp.
- Rope walls. Actually, I first saw this idea at ModHomeEc studio where I take my upholstery classes (a project featured in so many places, I’ll bet Design Star contestant Mikel got the idea there) but it still looked cool.
OK. On to the competition…
The challenge
This week’s challenge was the traditional white box room. Each contestant gets a 10x10-foot, three-walled room with a sofa, two lattice-sided end tables, rug, a simple white sofa (or maybe loveseat), a table lamp, and three plain cabinets. As you might have guessed, everything is white.
This year there is a little twist. The boxes have been constructed at Union Station in Los Angeles and the public is watching the designers’ progress.

The designers will get $1,000 and an hour to shop at a home improvement store for all the supplies they’ll use for the room.
Former winner David Bromstad – who is dressed in normal fitting clothes, thank goodness – tells the designers that the challenge is not to create a literal living space.
They should be more creative.
“You can do anything you want,” he tells them. “It does not have to be functional. But your room should express something about you and your design point of view.” Also, the designers must “transform” something.
Oh! And there’s going to be a camera challenge. I’m thrilled by this news. The winner will, after all, host a TV show.
First comes the shopping and you get the idea that Jordan (at right) is in trouble. He walks around aimlessly without a cart and finally – at the last minute – finds some Japanese-style garden pieces that he buys.
But it’s easy to see right away too that Bex has some interesting ideas for using PVC pipe and Stanley is going to do something innovative with lights.
Hilari had a neat idea to make her space feel like a jewelry box but acknowledges right away she has no idea how to use any tools. Hmm. That doesn’t bode well.
Here’s how everyone does:
Britany: She creates a beautiful space. Before painting the walls a deep blue, Britany uses tape to mask off lines that will look like molding. The finished walls are striking and look like a high-end dining room.
She’s the maker of the interesting chandelier I mentioned earlier with the chains, the inverted lamp and lattice panel. It’s a real focus and also serves as the piece she is transforming in her camera challenge. I love it and so do the judges.
On the back wall, Britany has hung an interesting wooden art piece, although we never get the story of how it’s made. There’s also a red and white striped rug.
Vanilla Ice (I just can’t call him by his real name, Robert Van Winkle) calls it “nautical.”
“My absolute favorite thing in here is the light fixture,” Vern Yipp says. “I love it when someone activates the ceiling.”
The third judge – Genevieve Gorder – says the gold touches make the room.
